The Best Lobster Rolls in Maine
When you think of Maine, you think of Lobster…right?! Our search for the perfect Maine lobster roll will be an ongoing pursuit, but in the meantime here is a list of some of our current favorites. If you’re visiting Maine, be sure to check out these spots! If you’re a local, we’d love to hear about your favorites!
The “Maine” style lobster roll consists of chilled lobster meat tossed with mayo served on a center cut toasted hot dog roll.
NOTE - Many of the spots in the below list are seasonal. Be sure to check with the restaurant ahead of time to confirm hours of operation and any COVID-19 related policies.
Lobster Rolls in Portland, Maine:
Bite into Maine (Allagash Brewing in Portland, Maine + Portland Head Lighthouse/Fort Williams Park in Cape Elizabeth)
Instagram Handle: @biteintomaine
Looking out at the ocean dotted with lobster buoys, alongside Portland Head Lighthouse enjoying a delicious lobster roll sounds “oh so Maine” in our book! While Bite into Maine has multiple locations, be sure to stop at their food truck located at Fort Williams Park in Cape Elizabeth - home of Portland Head Light. Trust us, this roll does not disappoint!
The Maine Style topped with chives and the Picnic Style including cole slaw on the bun.
Luke’s Lobster (Old Port - Portland, Maine)
Instagram Handle: @lukesportland
Luke’s Lobster has a beautiful oceanfront spot at the end of Portland Pier off Commercial Street in Portland’s Old Port. We love this spot for lobster rolls, the lobster BLT and their delicious haddock bites! Grab a cocktail or beer and experience the way life should be! Great outdoor dining options here too that are also pet friendly.
The Highroller Lobster Co. (Old Port - Portland, Maine)
Instagram Handle: @highrollerlobsterco
This lobster hot spot on upper Exchange Street in the Old Port is a fun spot to grab an insta worthy roll and cocktail. Their frozen drinks, served complete with an umbrella are fun and refreshing. In addition to the lobster roll, be sure to check out the surf and turf burger (that means a lobster topped burger!) and the red snapper corn dog. For those unfamiliar with the red snapper hot dog, it’s a Maine staple!
J’s Oyster (Old Port - Portland, Maine
Instagram Handle: @js_oyster
This is where the locals go! On your way down Portland Pier, the old school blue and white building is easy to miss. Step inside for a step back in time to a wood paneled bar and dining room. Their lobster roll is refreshingly priced at $18 with a healthy serving of fresh meat. We appreciate the little touch of lettuce too! Order an Allagash White for the perfect Maine pairing.
Lobster Rolls Beyond Portland, Maine:
Fisherman’s Catch (Wells, Maine)
Instagram Handle: @fishermanscatchwells
Way down the coast in Wells, Fisherman’s Catch serves up a delicious lobster roll. We love the outdoor patio seating, fun atmosphere, warm and friendly service and fun cocktails to accompany our lobster roll. This is also a great spot to meet up with friends.
Loads of fresh lobster meat, toasted bun with a touch of lettuce at Fisherman’s Catch in Wells.
Shannon’s Unshelled (Boothbay Harbor, Maine)
Instagram Handle: shannonsunshelled
If you find yourself headed to the mid-coast region, be sure to check out Shannon’s Unshelled in the heart of Boothbay Harbor. This hidden gem serves up a delicious roll. You can grab a growler of beer from neighboring Footbridge Brewing to enjoy with your lobster.
Lobster Roll, Beer Growler and side of drawn butter in Boothbay Harbor, Maine.
